(This rolls forward part of a previous change, now that jarjar was fixed
to not get very slow when the number of rules increases).
Jarjar rules are hard to keep in sync with code, and hard to maintain
manually as the distinction between what should and should not be
jarjared is not always clear. This results in unsafe binaries that are
manually maintained, and developer frustration when something fails due
to incorrect jarjar rules.
Add utility to autogenerate jarjar rules, which can be run at build time
time (via a genrule) instead. The generator scans pre-jarjar
intermediate artifacts, and outputs jarjar rules for every class to put
it in a package specific to the module. The only exceptions are:
- Classes that are API (module-lib API is the largest API surface of
the module, so module-lib API stubs would typically be used)
- Classes that have unsupportedappusage symbols
- Classes that are excluded manually (for example, because they have
hardcoded external references, like for
ConnectivityServiceInitializer in SystemServer).
Bug: 217129444
Test: atest jarjar-rules-generator-test;
Change-Id: I3493957e39a661b6c2e330944e7c3023b8f3203e
This reverts commit 53eb35cd82.
Reason for revert: b/233081774, caused long build times in FrameworkNetTests
Change-Id: Ide01c994f694b55fc0e87bb0e81584ac44196e68
Jarjar rules are hard to keep in sync with code, and hard to maintain
manually as the distinction between what should and should not be
jarjared is not always clear. This results in unsafe binaries that are
manually maintained, and developer frustration when something fails due
to incorrect jarjar rules.
Autogenerate jarjar rules at build time instead. This is achieved by
introducing a jarjar-rules-generator python-based library, which scans
pre-jarjar intermediate artifacts, and outputs jarjar rules for every
class to put it in a package specific to the module. The only exceptions
are:
- Classes that are API (module-lib API is the largest API surface of
the module)
- Classes that have unsupportedappusage symbols
- Classes that are excluded manually (for example, because they have
hardcoded external references, like for
ConnectivityServiceInitializer in SystemServer).
This change causes all classes in framework-connectivity(-t) and
service-connectivity to be jarjared into android.net.connectivity, but
still avoids jarjaring classes in com.android.server as before, to keep
it small.
For many classes this differs from the original jarjar rule.
Notes on implementation:
- connectivity-jarjar-rules now has a subset
framework-connectivity-jarjar-rules containing only the rules
necessary for framework-connectivity. This is necessary because
framework-connectivity cannot depend on rules generated based on
service-connectivity, as there would be a dependency cycle
(service-connectivity depends on framework-connectivity); Soong even
crashes with a stack overflow.
- framework-wifi.stubs.module_lib is added to
framework-connectivity-pre-jarjar as it is necessary to build it (it
is already in impl_only_libs in the defaults).
It is unclear why framework-connectivity-pre-jarjar could build
before that (possibly because it was only used as "lib" ?)
- Fix package-private visibility; for example NattSocketKeepalive,
TcpSocketKeepalive are not API so should be jarjared, but are used
by ConnectivityManager which is not jarjared, so they are not in the
same package after the change. Package-private members in the
former 2 need to be public to be accessible. Changes in this commit
are all that is needed, as demonstrated by followup commits that move
the classes to a different package without further changes, and that
enforce that no class in an API package gets jarjared.
- framework-connectivity-internal-test-defaults is separated from
framework-connectivity-test-defaults, for unit tests that need to
access internal jarjared classes. Such tests need to use the jarjar
rules themselves too, so this is only appropriate for connectivity
internal unit tests.
Test: atest ConnectivityCoverageTests CtsNetTestCases
Bug: 217129444
Change-Id: Ied17c3955ea2fda130089265d02908937ad8af1e
Remi NGUYEN VAN
commited 
Colin Cross
commited